877-415-4060
1018 E Oakhill Dr
Alpine, UT 84004

Learning Center • Alpine Groups • DBT Skills Training

DBT: Opposite Action and Problem Solving Skills

Opposite action changes a response to an emotion-driven urge when that response is not useful or the emotion does not fit the facts. Problem solving addresses an actual changeable situation. Use context, safety, consent, and resources to choose an approach; a situation can need both skills without requiring emotional calm first.

Updated: October 19, 2026

Most Major Insurance Plans Accepted
Private verification · Clear next steps · No pressure to commit.

DBT opposite action and problem solving lesson at Alpine Recovery Lodge
Back to DBT library

Change the response, address the problem, or do both

These DBT emotion-regulation skills have different purposes. Opposite action involves deliberately choosing behavior opposite to an emotion’s unhelpful action urge. Problem solving works on a practical situation that can be changed. Neither means that an emotion is fake or that a person should ignore a real need.

The choice is not simply “my urge or the situation is the problem.” Both can matter. An appropriate response may also involve acceptance, a chosen coping option, resources, advocacy, clinical care, or another form of support.

What you will practice

  • Separate a feeling from an urge and a practical problem.
  • Explain the conditions for considering opposite action.
  • Choose a feasible response, actual arrangement, and review.

Different purposes; the skills can be combined

Opposite actionConsider when an emotion or its intensity does not fit the facts, or acting on its urge would be ineffective. Choose an appropriate opposite action.
Problem solvingAddress an actual changeable problem by checking information, comparing feasible options, arranging an action, and reviewing the result.

Check the facts and the effectiveness of the urge

In DBT, opposite action is considered when an emotion, its intensity, or its duration does not fit the facts, or when acting on the emotion’s urge would be ineffective. These are different questions. An understandable feeling can coexist with an unhelpful urge.

Name the actual urge, such as sending an insulting reply, and identify an appropriate action that goes in the other direction. A neutral, specific question may be more useful than an insult. The action should fit the person’s goal, context, consent, access, and safety.

Practice concerns carrying out the chosen suitable response, not just naming a skill. It does not require pretending to feel differently, suppressing thoughts, becoming cheerful, adopting a prescribed posture, or repeating an exercise until relief arrives. Seek an appropriate clinician’s guidance for personal clinical use.

Opposite action is not a general instruction to approach danger, disclose private information, ignore pain, contact someone unsafe, or reverse a prescribed care plan. Fear and other feelings can signal a real need for protection or assessment.

Turn a real barrier into a feasible action plan

  1. Describe the situation: distinguish known information from assumptions and check relevant details.
  2. Name a realistic goal: identify what needs changing and what is within the available options.
  3. Consider alternatives: include practical help, access changes, appropriate services, or advocacy when relevant.
  4. Choose and arrange an option: confirm the person, timing, access, responsibility, and any needed backup.
  5. Review the result: check what happened and adapt or seek appropriate help if the need remains unresolved.

An idea is not yet an available resource. An unanswered request is not a confirmed arrangement. A skill cannot make an inaccessible system accessible by itself or guarantee another person’s decision.

If the situation cannot be changed immediately, a chosen coping or acceptance skill may support a next step while practical or clinical needs are addressed. No one needs to feel calm before arranging appropriate help.

Worked examples: an urge and an actual access problem

Fictional example one: Cory is trying to obtain information about a non-urgent class. A printer error prevents a volunteer from providing the sheet. Cory feels frustrated and has an urge to insult the volunteer. Cory wants accurate joining information.

Opposite-action purpose: frustration can make sense, while an insult does not help Cory obtain the details. Cory chooses a neutral question: “Is there another accessible way to get the joining information?” This changes the response to the urge without requiring Cory to feel pleased.

Problem-solving purpose: the information is still needed. Cory checks whether an accessible copy, an appropriate staff contact, or another suitable route is available. Cory confirms the details before relying on them. The response and the access problem can be addressed together.

Fictional example two: a listed class time conflicts with Lee’s work shift. The conflict is a practical fact, not evidence that Lee’s feeling is wrong. Lee can ask about a different suitable session, check its availability and access, or consider an appropriate alternative. Emotional regulation cannot create a session that does not exist.

Check your understanding

Was Cory’s frustration proved false? No. The lesson distinguishes an understandable feeling from an ineffective action urge.

Did Cory have to become calm before asking? No. The chosen communication can be neutral and clear while frustration remains.

Would opposite action alone fix Lee’s timetable? No. The actual scheduling and access problem needs a feasible arrangement or another appropriate route.

Do not turn a skill into an automatic rule about a feeling

Avoid automatic emotion-to-action rules

1Feeling is not an instructionAnger can fit an event while insulting someone is ineffective.
2Privacy is not failureShame does not create a duty to disclose a secret or contact someone.
3Rest can be appropriateSadness does not make all solitude or rest an unhelpful behavior.
4Resources still matterA coping action cannot create transport, access, care, or a service that is unavailable.

“Shame means disclose,” “fear means approach,” and “sadness means socialize” omit important context. Privacy, rest, distance, and protective behavior can be appropriate. Do not infer a person’s need, motive, safety, or willingness from an emotion label.

Cravings, panic symptoms, withdrawal, and other clinical concerns should not be reduced to choosing the opposite behavior. Use appropriate assessment, treatment, and individualized plans. A public worksheet does not establish the cause of symptoms or decide risk.

Prompts for choosing an appropriate response

1Describe the known event and any uncertainty.
2Name the feeling and the specific action urge separately.
3Consider facts, context, safety, and effectiveness.
4Choose a suitable action and address real resources or access needs.
5Review what happened without requiring instant emotional relief.

Review the action and the actual result, including access, resources, and any unresolved need. Continuing feelings are not a grade. An unsuitable practice should be adapted or stopped rather than pursued as proof of effort.

Protection and appropriate care do not wait for a skill

Do not use opposite action as a self-directed exposure program, an instruction to confront someone, or a reason to ignore danger or medical symptoms. Qualified individual guidance is important for clinical concerns. Problem solving does not replace emergency response.

Call 911 for suspected overdose, serious breathing difficulty, unresponsiveness, seizure, severe confusion, hallucinations, chest pain, immediate danger, or another medical emergency. For possible opioid overdose, give naloxone if available and follow its instructions and the dispatcher’s directions.

Withdrawal concerns, especially after reducing or stopping alcohol or benzodiazepines, need qualified medical guidance. Do not start, stop, or adjust medicines or attempt a withdrawal plan through this page. Severe distress or difficulty staying safe needs urgent professional help; immediate danger requires emergency help.

Do not delay urgent care for a worksheet, admissions call, or insurance verification.

When abuse or coercion is present, a survivor is not responsible for preventing another person’s abuse through a different emotion or better words. Appropriate specialist support may be needed rather than direct contact or negotiation.

Optional practice: Cory’s response and access plan

Use Cory’s fictional printer example, Lee’s schedule example, another low-stakes situation, or pass. This unscored exercise teaches distinctions; it is not a clinical decision rule, risk assessment, or treatment plan.

Leave out names, personal histories, contacts, and private health information. Entries do not arrange care or alert anyone and may be lost when you leave or refresh. Protect printed or saved copies.

Choose appropriate support for actual needs

Alpine Recovery Lodge offers social detox for adults 18 and older. It does not provide medical detox, medication-assisted treatment, or 24/7 nursing. If you need medical withdrawal management or medication treatment, seek an appropriate medical provider before entering a program that cannot provide that level of care. Coordinate existing prescribed care with the relevant provider.

For non-emergency information about actual services or referrals, contact Alpine admissions. Confirm suitability and availability. Admissions does not replace a clinical assessment or emergency care.

For facilitators and supporters

Use the printer or schedule example and allow a pass or an accessible response method. Ask learners to identify the urge and the practical problem separately. Do not require public disclosure, approach to a feared person, body exercises, or a display of calm. Clinical treatment choices need appropriate individualized guidance.

Questions about opposite action and practical problem solving

What is opposite action for?

Deliberately choosing an appropriate action opposite to an unhelpful emotion-driven urge when the emotion or its intensity does not fit the facts, or acting on the urge would be ineffective.

Can an emotion fit the facts while the urge is ineffective?

Yes. Frustration about a printer error can make sense while insulting the volunteer does not help obtain information. Consider the feeling and the proposed action separately.

What does problem solving address?

An actual changeable situation. Check information, identify a realistic goal, consider feasible options, arrange an action, and review what happened.

Can I use both skills in one situation?

Yes. A person may choose a more useful response to an urge while also arranging practical help or addressing an access barrier. There is no universal order requiring calm first.

Does shame mean I must disclose something?

No. An emotion label does not create a duty to disclose, contact someone, or abandon privacy. Context, consent, and safety matter.

Does sadness make rest or time alone wrong?

No. Rest, solitude, support, or another response can fit different circumstances. A public lesson cannot decide what every person needs from the emotion name alone.

Must the feeling disappear for the action to be useful?

No. Review the action, goal, actual arrangements, and unresolved needs. Instant relief is not required and is not guaranteed.

Can these skills replace medical care or a safety plan?

No. Symptoms, dangerous situations, withdrawal concerns, and treatment needs require the appropriate qualified response. Do not delay urgent care for a worksheet.

Sources and further learning

The revised visuals, fictional examples, and planner are educational aids, not standardized DBT measures, a clinical algorithm, or an individualized exposure or safety plan.

Continue learning

Previous: Opposite Action · DBT Skills library · Next: Navigating Strong Emotions: Pros, Cons, and Solutions

CONTINUE WITH A CLEAR NEXT STEP

Where to go next

Recommended next step

Navigating Strong Emotions: Pros, Cons, and Solutions

See how this DBT skill can be used in everyday recovery situations.

Browse this topic: DBT Skills Training

Browse all Alpine resources