Jump to Section
Use this quick menu to move through the lesson. This page is educational and is not a diagnosis, therapy session, or replacement for professional care.
Quick Educational Answer
DBT pros and cons is a decision-making skill that helps people compare the short-term payoff and long-term cost of acting on an emotional urge before they act.
This matters in recovery because strong emotions can create fast urges: use, isolate, lash out, avoid, hide, self-sabotage, or contact unsafe people. Pros, cons, and solutions help slow the moment down so the person can choose what works, not only what feels immediate.
Helpful outside education on DBT and emotional health can be found through Behavioral Tech’s DBT overview, NIMH mental health education, and SAMHSA mental health resources.
Simple Explanation: The Urge Is Not Always the Answer
Strong emotions are not the problem by themselves. The bigger risk is often what happens next. Anger may create an urge to attack. Shame may create an urge to hide. Fear may create an urge to avoid. Cravings may create an urge to chase quick relief.
DBT pros and cons helps the person pause long enough to see the full picture. The first urge may offer short-term relief, but it may also create long-term damage. A solution gives the person a healthier next step that protects recovery and reduces harm.
Alpine Recovery Lodge uses practical skill-building alongside substance abuse treatment, mental health treatment, dual diagnosis care, and trauma-informed treatment.
| Strong emotion | Common urge | Possible solution |
|---|---|---|
| Anger | Yell, blame, send the text, threaten, or cut someone off. | Pause, cool down, write without sending, return later with Wise Mind. |
| Fear | Avoid, hide, cancel, escape, or refuse the next step. | Take one safe step, ask for support, check the facts, and stay present. |
| Shame | Lie, isolate, disappear, avoid accountability, or give up. | Tell the truth to one safe person, make a repair plan, and stay connected. |
| Sadness | Withdraw, stay in bed, stop trying, or disconnect. | Use gentle structure, reach out, take one small action, and reduce isolation. |
| Craving | Use substances, romanticize use, contact risky people, or chase relief. | Leave the trigger, call support, use grounding, and ride out the urge. |
What Strong Emotions Can Feel Like
Strong emotions can feel like the whole body is demanding action. The urge may feel urgent, convincing, and impossible to ignore, even when part of the person knows the action could make things worse.
In the Body
Racing heart, tight chest, heat, tension, shaking, stomach drop, numbness, restlessness, or pressure to move fast.
In the Mind
All-or-nothing thinking, “I can’t handle this,” “I need relief now,” “They deserve it,” or “Nothing matters.”
In Behavior
Using substances, lashing out, hiding, shutting down, self-sabotaging, leaving, over-texting, or avoiding support.
Important safety note
This lesson is educational. If someone is at risk of self-harm, overdose, severe withdrawal, violence, abuse, or immediate danger, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room.
Why Emotional Urges Can Feel So Powerful
Emotional urges can feel powerful because the brain and body are trying to reduce discomfort quickly. The problem is that fast relief is not always effective relief. A behavior may lower pain for a few minutes while creating relapse risk, shame, broken trust, conflict, or danger later.
DBT skills help the person create a pause between the feeling and the action. That pause is where recovery choices become possible.
How Pros and Cons Work in DBT
Pros and cons helps people compare the short-term and long-term effects of acting on an urge versus resisting it.
1. Name the emotion
Start with the actual emotion: anger, fear, shame, sadness, loneliness, grief, anxiety, or craving.
2. Name the urge
Ask, “What is this emotion pushing me to do right now?”
3. List the pros of acting on the urge
Be honest about the short-term payoff: relief, escape, control, release, or numbing.
4. List the cons of acting on the urge
Name the real costs: relapse risk, shame, consequences, conflict, health risk, or broken trust.
5. List the pros of resisting the urge
Look at what resisting protects: recovery, safety, trust, self-respect, health, and long-term goals.
6. Choose one solution
End with an action step that can be done now, not a vague promise to “do better.”
Healthier Solutions for Strong Emotions
A solution is the next action that helps without making the situation worse. It does not have to fix everything. It needs to move the person toward safety, recovery, and stability.
Pause First
Wait 10 to 20 minutes before acting on a high-risk urge.
Change Location
Leave a risky environment, step outside, or move into a safer space.
Contact Support
Call staff, a therapist, sponsor, family member, or safe support person.
Use Opposite Action
Act opposite to shame, fear, anger, or cravings when the urge would cause harm.
Use Grounding
Use breathing, sensory grounding, cold water, or present-moment awareness.
Problem Solve
Identify one practical next step instead of trying to solve the whole problem at once.
What Makes This Skill Harder
- Only focusing on short-term relief.
- Believing a strong urge must be obeyed.
- Skipping the long-term consequences.
- Choosing vague solutions instead of specific actions.
- Waiting until the emotion is already at a 10 out of 10.
- Trying to think clearly without first calming the body.
- Stopping at insight without follow-through.
What Helps
Pros, cons, and solutions work best when they are simple enough to use in real life. The goal is not to write a perfect essay. The goal is to slow down the urge and choose one next step that protects recovery.
- Write the urge in one sentence.
- Name the short-term payoff honestly.
- Name the long-term cost clearly.
- Ask, “What would help me most tomorrow, not just right now?”
- Choose one practical solution you can do within the next few minutes.
- Pair this skill with Emotion Regulation Skills, Opposite Action, and Distress Tolerance Skills.
For clients who need more structure, Alpine offers residential treatment, day treatment / PHP, IOP, and aftercare and alumni support.
Interactive Self-Check: What Is the Urge Costing Me?
This self-check is educational only. It is not a diagnosis. Use it to slow down a strong emotion and choose a healthier next step.
Your reflection
Alpine Insight: What We Commonly See
At Alpine Recovery Lodge, many clients already know what the “right” long-term choice is when they are calm. The challenge is remembering that choice when an emotion becomes loud. Pros and cons gives clients a structure for slowing down before the urge takes over.
We commonly see this skill help clients understand that an urge can feel powerful without being wise. Once the urge is slowed down, healthier solutions become easier to see.
Common Mistakes: What Not to Do
- Do not treat short-term relief as the only “pro.”
- Do not skip the long-term costs.
- Do not shame yourself for having the urge.
- Do not choose a solution that keeps you isolated with a high-risk urge.
- Do not wait until safety is at risk before asking for help.
- Do not use this worksheet instead of emergency care when immediate danger is present.
Related Treatment Options
Navigating strong emotions can support people working through cravings, anger, shame, trauma responses, anxiety, relapse risk, and dual diagnosis concerns. These skills may be practiced in mental health treatment, dual diagnosis care, substance abuse treatment, and trauma-informed treatment.
This lesson also connects closely with Alpine’s Balancing Decisions and Emotions, Checking the Facts, and TIPP Skills for Crisis Survival lessons.
What Happens First If Someone Reaches Out?
If someone contacts Alpine Recovery Lodge, admissions starts by listening. The team may ask a few basic questions about substance use, mental health symptoms, emotional safety, treatment history, and timing.
Alpine can also privately verify insurance benefits, explain possible options, and help the person understand what may make sense before committing. There is no pressure to commit, and if Alpine is not the right fit, the team can still offer guidance.
Most Major Insurance Plans Accepted
Alpine Recovery Lodge works with many major insurance providers. Our admissions team can privately verify your benefits, explain your estimated coverage, and help you understand your options before you commit.
What Should I Do Next?
1. I’m still learning.
Start by choosing one recent emotional urge and writing the pros, cons, and one healthier solution. Use the printable worksheet and keep exploring the DBT Skills Training Library.
2. I’m worried about myself or someone else.
Pay attention to urges connected to relapse, self-harm, overdose risk, unsafe withdrawal, violence, or immediate danger. If there is an urgent safety concern, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room.
3. I’m ready to talk to someone.
Reach out to admissions or verify insurance privately. You can ask questions, understand options, and decide what makes sense without pressure.
Printable Strong Emotions Worksheet
Use the buttons under the hero image to print this lesson or open a print-friendly version. The worksheet helps you name the emotion, identify the urge, compare pros and cons, and choose one healthier solution.
Frequently Asked Questions About Navigating Strong Emotions
What does DBT mean by pros and cons?
Pros and cons in DBT means comparing the short-term and long-term effects of an urge or choice before acting on it.
Why is this skill important in recovery?
It is important because many harmful choices feel good in the short term but carry larger long-term costs for recovery, trust, safety, and stability.
What does “solutions” mean in this lesson?
Solutions means choosing a practical next step that supports recovery instead of only reacting to the emotion.
Can this help with cravings and conflict?
Yes. These skills can help people slow down during cravings, anger, shame, conflict, and other high-intensity moments.
What is an example of using pros and cons?
If someone feels a craving, they can list the short-term relief of using, the long-term costs of using, the benefits of resisting, and one safer solution such as calling support or leaving a trigger.
Can these skills still help after treatment ends?
Yes. These skills can continue helping with everyday stress, urges, conflict, and recovery decision-making long after treatment ends.
Strong Emotions Do Not Have to Decide the Outcome
Pros, cons, and solutions help people slow down, compare outcomes, and choose a next step that protects recovery. If emotions, cravings, trauma responses, or mental health symptoms are making recovery harder, Alpine Recovery Lodge can help you understand treatment options and next steps.
Most major insurance plans are accepted, and the admissions team can help you verify benefits privately before you commit.
